The Top 5 wine of the month clubs for value shoppers
Last updated: December 6, 2014
If you’re looking for the best value in a wine club, you’ve found the right place. There are a lot of cheap wine clubs out there, but not all of these clubs actually deliver great value. Some wine clubs excel at driving the purchase price of each bottle down and passing the savings on to you, other clubs taste extensively and always find the best wines available at bargain prices, and still others look for good-quality wines from inexpensive wine regions.
No matter what their wine-buying strategy is, some clubs consistently deliver great value in their wine shipments. Better still, some take the value further, by subsidizing the shipping cost of the wine, offering freebies, and providing members-only discounts on reorders.
Overview: Club W is a new kind of wine club—get a personalized list of available selections each month and then choose your own wine. Very flexible in size of shipment and what goes in the box each month. This makes for a great gift, too!
What We Love: We love the great selection of quirky wines mostly priced at $13 with some better wines sprinkled in. We are especially impressed with the whites and roses which deliver knockout value. We love that you can put as many wines in your box as you want, and that shipping is free on 6 or more bottles.
Could Be Better: The wine descriptions tend to purposely avoid helpful terms that experienced wine drinkers look for in selecting bottles (i.e., no references to "buttery" or "acidic"), and the red wines haven't been our cup of tea. It's hard to sell a good red wine for $13, but we think they can do better here.
Overview: Two bottles just not enough for you? We understand. Try this bigger version of the incredibly popular Classic Series wine club.
What We Love: We love that Paul streams his wine-tasting sessions live over the Internet so we can see what he's tasting and how much he's rejected.
Could Be Better: We'd love to see this offered on a monthly basis, too!
Limited Time Offer
Take a 30-second wine survey and save $30 on the wine tasting kit today! Your first personalized case will be 50% off the normal price.
Overview: A personalized wine program powered that gets to know your palate by starting your subscription with a tasting kit—real wine tasting in your living room. A significant step up from anonymous case clubs.
What We Love: Lot18 delivers on value, but at a higher level than other case clubs you might be considering. These selections are tailored to your preferences and they send exclusive wines you won't find anywhere else. Online account management is a big plus.
Could Be Better: We've had some complaints about quality. This is probably more a factor of their high-end marketing push which makes buyers think these are exceptional wines, when really, they're just good wines. Fortunately, they've just made a major upgrade to their customer service procedures and added a phone line, so we think they're heading in the right direction.
Overview: An incredibly popular wine club delivering the highest-quality wines among the two-bottle monthly wine clubs.
What We Love: Consistency. We've been receiving their shipments for years and we've never had a wine we didn't like. You can't really ask for more than that from a wine club.
Could Be Better: We don't have any suggestions for what to improve within the Gold Series wine club. Yay!
Overview: For red wine lovers, a dedicated club is an excellent choice. In addition to selecting unusual reds, especially compared to similar wine clubs, Direct Cellars has a great rewards program where you can get free wine every month.
What We Love: To us, the best part of Direct Cellars is that reorders—you know, the wines you like the most and want more of—are sold to you at a penny above Direct Cellars cost! Their killer referral program means you can get your monthly shipments for free.
Could Be Better: Direct Cellars is designed to deliver extraordinary value—like free shipping. It means they don't have all the bells-and-whistles of other wine clubs, specifically a gift option or a satisfaction guarantee.
We've hand-selected these wine clubs for you because: They exceed our expectations as compared to similar wine clubs; They offer better value or a better selection of wines than similar wine of the month clubs; Our readers prefer these to similar clubs.
Looking for the best affordable wine clubs? Our editors have carefully scrutinized budget-oriented wine clubs to help you extract the most value and enjoyment out of your wine-club dollars.
The best red wine clubs are a mix of two things: the best wine clubs overall, and getting the most value on red wine (which can be expensive for the good stuff). We sifted through our independent wine club reviews to figure out which wine clubs are really the best red wine clubs. These red wine clubs are sure to delight.
Not surprisingly, there are a number of amazing values in white wine clubs. Since white wine is often cheaper than read for similar quality, we went even further with our best white wine clubs list, looking for the clubs that offer you interesting whites, not just good whites. Use our reviews to further refine your selection.
Seen one of those great offers for a super cheap case of wine and want to know which one is really the best quarterly case wine club? Well, we’ve looked at ‘em all... and most of them aren’t worth it. Here are a handful of quarterly case clubs that pass our test to be called best.
Looking for a cut above the regular wine selection in your next monthly club? Try one of these Premium wine clubs. The wines typically cost a little more, but you’ll find you have access to a more unique selection, and wines that are much harder to find at your local store or in another wine club.
Try one of these articles to help you find the best club for your needs: