Editor's Picks

The 5 Wine Clubs We'd Most Likely Join

  1. #1 Signature Series Wine Club
  2. #2 Pinot Noir Series Wine Club
  3. #3 Plonk Mixed Wine Club
  4. #4 Champagne Club

Read more about these wine clubs below, or get the full reviews by clicking these links.

Last updated: March 6, 2016

We've sampled shipments from nearly every wine club on our site, and even from many wine clubs that aren't working with us any longer. We get these shipments for free, so there's really never a reason for us to join a wine club. That said, some incredible wine clubs come across our desks. If were going to buy a wine club, for ourselves or as a gift, it would be one of these five.

We chose a wine club for each type of wine we drink throughout the week, making sure we always have something on hand that we can't wait to open. Across all levels, these are our definitive Editor's Picks for best wine clubs.

Note: This list is different than our other Best Wine Clubs which take into account general consumer preferences, our reader's favorite wine clubs, and those we think deliver the most value. We're not really average wine drinkers around here anymore, so this list is reflective our personal tastes.

Ships to

    Limited Time Offer
    WineClubReviews Exclusive! Save 50% on your first shipment when enrolling in an ongoing subscription of the Signature Series. Use coupon code WCRHALF

    Giving a Gift? Get three months of free shipping with any gift of three months or longer.

    For ultra-premium California wines, I can't think of a wine club I'd rather see arrive at my door. These hand-selected small-production gems represent the very finest California has to offer in collectible and drinkable wine. Stunning depth, roundness, balance, and fruit-forwardness will delight you with every sip.

    Offered monthly, bi-monthly, and quarterly—so no matter how often you have a special occasion, you'll always have the perfect wine to celebrate on hand.

    * Insider's Tip! You'll save by buying a pre-paid subscription "gift" for yourself. Buy 6 shipments and save 10%, buy 12 and save 15%. Use our exclusive coupon code WCR25 and save $25 on your first month's shipment.

    Shopping Last Minute? The California Wine Club has custom gift cards you can print or email to your recipient so they have something to open on the big day.

    Read Our ReviewGo Directly to the Wine Club

  1. by Gold Medal Wine Club

    Limited Time Offer
    Buy more, save more! Save 5% on 12-month gifts. No coupon needed.

    When it comes to Pinot Noir, we're pretty finicky. We have a strong preference for California Pinots, with all of the fruity, juicy, cola flavors we can get. While we go gaga for Russian River Valley Pinot Noir, we're serious sippers of Santa Barbara County (especially Santa Ynez), and Central Coast Pinots, too.

    The Gold Medal Pinot Series features only California Pinot Noir from top wineries. Every month needs a little Pinot Noir in it, so this club holds a place on this list.

    Read Our ReviewGo Directly to the Wine Club

  2. by Plonk Wine Club

    Limited Time Offer
    Save $10 on any order with promo code NEWMEMBER.

    Bonus: Get a FREE double-hinged corkscrew with your first shipment. If you've never used one, you'll see why it's the best way to open a bottle of wine!

    It's no secret, we love the Plonk Wine Club. We've been big fans for years and they just recently launched a case club (12 bottles) for those of us who really can't get enough. It's the normal 4-bottle shipment but you get three each of these fun, easy-drinking and adventurous wines.

    By ordering the 12-bottle club, you save almost 20% over the 2-bottle pricing and you'll always have your favorite selections in triplicate.

    * Insider's Tip! Get a 10% discount on all reorders and a 25% discount on shipping for 12-bottle reorders.

    Read Our ReviewGo Directly to the Wine Club

  3. by Henri's Reserve

    Champagne is one of life's little luxuries, it's expensive but it also brings joy to any day of the week. Treat yourself or give it as a gift, Henri's Reserve will tickle anyone's tongue with delight with small wineries from Champagne, France that don't always make it out of France.

    Offered monthly, bi-monthly, and quarterly—so no matter how often you have a special occasion, you'll always have the perfect bubbly to celebrate on hand.

    Read Our ReviewGo Directly to the Wine Club

More Lists of the Best Wine Clubs

The Top 5 Best Wine Clubs

The Top 5 Best Wine Clubs

Our best wine clubs list highlights 5 clubs that offer the best of what a wine club should be. We use 11 ratings factors and have reviewed hundreds of wine clubs.

See the The Top 5 Best Wine Clubs

Best Quarterly Case Wine Clubs

Best Quarterly Case Wine Clubs

Find budget nirvana by combining two smart wine shopping tactics: Buy by the case, get a subscription. These are the best quarterly case clubs on the market.

See the Best Quarterly Case Wine Clubs

Best Premium Wine Clubs

Best Premium Wine Clubs

Looking for a cut above the regular wine selection in your next monthly club? Try one of these Premium wine clubs. The wines typically cost a little more, but you’ll find you have access to a more unique selection, and wines that are much harder to find at your local store or in another wine club.

See the Best Premium Wine Clubs

Most Interesting Wine Clubs

Most Interesting Wine Clubs

There are many “standard” two-bottle of the month wine clubs out there—one white, one red, virtually (and often literally) guaranteed not offend anyone. But if you’re intrigued by the unusual, distinctive, or boutique wines of the world, we suggest you take a look at this list of Most Interesting wine clubs.

See the Most Interesting Wine Clubs

See all of the best wine clubs lists

Need a different kind of buying advice?

  • Are Wine Clubs a Good Deal?

    In this article: How to tell when a wine club isn't a good value; why we think wine clubs are totally worth it; and how to squeeze even more value out of your wine club.
  • Wine Club Buying Guide

    In this article: What type of wine club should I join? Some tips for joining wine clubs.
  • Wine Gift Buying Guide

    In this article: How do I know which wine gift to choose? The fast and easy way to buy a wine club gift; and the more customized approach to buying a wine club gift.