Last updated: February 12, 2019
Please note: if you join or give a wine club after clicking our links we might earn a commission.
|Rank||Wine Subscriptions||Bottles per Box|
|1||WINC Wine Club||4 per shipment|
|2||Nakedwines.com Wine Subscription||You choose|
|3||Firstleaf Wine Subscription||6 per shipment|
|4||90+ Cellars Wine Club||6 per shipment|
|5||TastingRoom.com||12 per shipment|
|6||Martha Stewart Wine Club||6 per shipment|
|7||Case Club||12 per shipment|
|8||90+ Wine Club||12 per shipment|
|9||The Cellar Series Wine Club||6 per shipment|
|10||Wine Awesomeness Wine Club||3 per shipment|
|11||WSJwine Wine Club||12 per shipment|
After almost 10 years of wine club reviews, we know why the best affordable wine clubs are better wine subscriptions than other inexpensive wine clubs.
Affordable wine of the month clubs on this list:
We Drink the Wine. We've received many shipments from every one of these wine clubs (except where noted) and keep close tabs on the quality of the wine.
Cheap Wine or Good Value? Some cheap wine clubs ship cheap wine. If your idea of affordable includes good value, try our Best Value Wine Clubs list instead.
Winc appears on many of our Best Wine Clubs lists for a good reason — it's a great wine club. They're so great because they think of their subscription customers as their favorite customers, bestowing up on these loyal wine drinkers their best prices, their best savings offers, and the coolest specials.
Winc is #1 on the Best Affordable list because it's also the most affordable wine of the month club we know of — as noted above, we've set the standard of affordability at $15 per bottle or less, delivered.
In addition to very affordable pricing — wines start at $13 per bottle and roughly 60% of their inventory is available at this price — Winc offers our readers a rare $25 discount on your first shipment, free shipping on every order of four or more bottles, and industry-leading levels of personalization.
Some other things we really like about Winc include additional savings opportunities like getting $10 in credits for rating 10 wines, saving 10% on orders of 12 bottles or more, and pre-buying credits at a discount of up to 20% off. We also love their focus on environmental sustainability and of course, a 100% satisfaction guarantee — "Never pay for a bottle you don't like."
The Caveat: While we think the red wines priced $18 and up are a good value, we typically find the $13 reds to be lacking. This is true of every wine of the month club on this list, except #7.
Winc makes a great gift! We've heard from some people that they'd rather not give a gift where the recipient has to pick their own wines. They don't have to at Winc, but they can if they want to. We love this. Gift memberships are given as gift cards in amounts starting at $60.
Nakedwines.com isn't a new wine club, but we've only recently formally reviewed them. And we're sorry we waited. We were absolutely impressed with the 6-bottle introductory shipment we received. Before we get into that, it's important to know that Nakedwines.com isn't exactly a regular wine club, it's more of a wine-buying membership where your membership fees go toward your wine purchases and any unspent funds are fully refundable.
There are so many reasons to love Nakedwines.com and we outline them all in our full review, but here is a sampling of our favorite features:
A huge variety of wine is available. No matter what your existing wine preferences are, or how much wine tasting your way through the world you want to do, you'll find you can create a fantastic wine subscription with their inventory. All kinds of red wine, white wine, sparkling and champagne are available. Every wine is described so you know if it's on the sweeter side, the drier side, or somewhere in between. Wine prices vary widely from $8 (a deeply discounted member price) to $45 with a great selection under $15.
You pick your own wine with the benefit of other members' ratings. This isn't just a personalized pick-em-yourself wine club, they make recommendations based on how you've rated your previous wines, but those ratings are shared with their customers, and the public, so you can pick only the most popular ones if you want.
You have a relationship with the winemakers. Your monthly deposits ensure there are funds to pay independent winemakers for the gems they produce. The winemakers are grateful for this way of working, as it allows them to be creative and guarantees them an income. We know this because when you comment on one of their wines, good or bad, odds are good you'll get a helpful or grateful response from the winemaker directly. It makes you feel good about buying your wine from Nakedwines.com.
A great introductory deal. We love it when wine clubs offer an low-cost offer to try their wares and Nakedwines.com has two options for you: a six-bottle deal for $49.99 or a 12-bottle deal for $89.99. Note: You don't get to pick the wines in this deal, so you may not love everything the way you would if you picked your own wine.
We think Firstleaf is a great choice for an affordable wine of the month club. At $15 a bottle (includes shipping), we find the wine to be better quality than many of the other wine subscription boxes in this price range.
Firstleaf is a personalized wine club. This means the wines you receive are selected for you based on what they know about your preferences. Like other personalized clubs, you start your membership with a palate quiz, and then you rate your wines so they can learn about what you like. This is different than a curated club which sends all of their customers the same wines.
From what we can tell, the Firstleaf wine-selection technology is more sophisticated than other popular clubs like WSJwine or TastingRoom.com. They leverage a great deal of data science, and even chemical profiling of their wines, to get better matches to your preferences. Firstleaf also uses a much broader inventory of wines, further increasing their chances of picking the right wines for your preferences. As compared with other personalized wine clubs, we found Firstleaf learns your preferences the fastest, though it still takes a few shipments.
Like most wine clubs featuring inexpensive wine, the white wine is superior to the red wine. Unlike most cheaper wine clubs, Firstleaf also lets you opt in to rosé and sparkling wine — which we love. You can choose California wine, International wine, or a mix (first select during the palate quiz, but you can change this any time). You can also specify how many of each type of wine you'd like (for example, instead of 3 whites and reds, you can do 2 whites and 4 reds).
After you sign up, you can change your shipment frequency to every two months or every three months, and you can change this at any time, making it easy to plan around company or travel plans.
We love the "try before you buy" option. $40 gets you a 6-bottle wine shipment to check out their quality and see if the subscription suits you. Future shipments are 6 bottles and you are automatically enrolled in the wine club when you order the introductory wine pack.
Ninety Plus Cellars is a different kind of wine club. Delivered quarterly, it's perfect for wine lovers who really appreciate good value and aren't looking to spend a lot of money discovering new wines. This wine club is inexpensive, affordably priced at $50 for 3-bottle shipments, shipping included.
What makes 90+ Cellars Wine Club unique is the underlying way they do business. They are a modern-day négociant — which means they source wine at every stage of the production cycle, from grapes growing in the vineyard to wine that's already been bottled — which gives them the opportunity to purchase great wine at deep discounts, and then pass that savings on to you. (Cameron Hughes and Kirkland brand wines from Costco use the exact same business model.)
These aren't "anonymous" wine blends, they showcase the best grapes from the grapes' best wine regions. Think Barolo from Piedmont, Rosé from Provence, Chardonnay from Russian River Valley, etc.
Save even more. As with most wine subscriptions on our Affordable list, you are rewarded for committing to a larger purchase. If you sign up for a 6-bottle membership, you'll get six different wines in each shipment and you'll also get a 5% discount and a 12-bottle membership saves you 10%.
When you're looking at wine clubs priced under $15 per bottle, it's a good idea to consider TastingRoom by Lot 18. Most people are introduced to this wine club via their $6.95 wine tasting kit experience, but we think that's not the reason to try this wine club and it's definitely not the reason you'll stay with this wine club.
At $15 a bottle the wine should be good, but you shouldn't expect it to be great. Sometimes you'll find an absolute winner for your taste buds, and likewise you might find a stinker (which they'll replace at no cost to you), but in general, their wines are good for the price.
What makes TastingRoom.com stand out though is that they are a full-fledged online subscription service offering every convenience you might expect from such a service. Using data they collect, both from you when you rate your wines and from their other customers, they make recommendations for the wines in your monthly, bi-monthly, or quarterly box. But like other personalized wine subscriptions: you can preview and change every single wine in the box if you want to.
TastingRoom.com is also really good at notifications and online interactions. You'll be notified a few weeks before your shipment is ready to go out and you can easily change the shipment date, change the wines in the box, or even change the size/frequency of your deliveries. And... you can cancel online (which hardly anyone lets you do).
All that said, TastingRoom.com doesn't have a stellar reputation among consumers and we strongly recommend reading our full review before you sign up. Of course, since you've read this far, you know you'll be signing up for automatic wine club shipments when you order the tasting kit and since you're reading our website, you'll also know that the first shipment of wine you receive has no relationship to how you rated the bottles shipped in the tasting kit.
Overview: A six or 12-bottle wine subscription geared toward occasional drinkers who don't want to spend a lot on their wine. An International selection with a good variety of wines and wine regions.
What We Love: There isn't anything Martha Stewart does that isn't beautiful, and the branding and experience of this wine subscription program are no exception to that rule.
Could Be Better: While we really enjoyed the white wines we received, the reds left much to be desired.
Overview: Among all of the case clubs (12 bottles, typically shipped quarterly), this California wine club offering selections from boutique wineries is one of the two best deals. The other club delivers 90+ point wine from around the world.
What We Love: We asked The California Wine Club for a case club deal and they made one! And now you get to save a TON of money on their already affordable Premier Series wines.
Could Be Better: Normally we'd ask for a deal for this club, but it's already priced as low as it can go, so it's perfect as is!
Overview: Among all of the case clubs (12 bottles, typically shipped quarterly), this 90+ International wine club is among the best two deals. The other focuses only on California wine, but this one takes you on a journey around the world. Enjoy eclectic wines at the best prices you'll find.
What We Love: It's so easy to get into a wine rut and stick with what you know. Wired For Wine ® helps you break out of that rut in a low-cost, satisfaction guaranteed way so you can find new wines to love. Also, when compared with similarly-priced case clubs, this one stands out for wine quality in a big way.
Could Be Better: Normally we'd ask for a deal for this club, but it's already priced as low as it can go, so it's nearly perfect as is! We'd love to see a little bit of customization available and also monthly clubs for people who drink more than a bottle a week.
Overview: The Cellar Series is the 6-bottle upgrade for each of the Wine of the Month Club's standard 2-bottle series: Classic, Vintners, and Limited. If their selection works for you, you can now get six bottles per shipment, which lowers your per-bottle shipping cost.
What We Love: Paul Kalemkiarian, second generation proprietor at Wine of the Month Club ™ goes out of his way to source interesting wines, and in this price point that can be a challenge, particularly in finding California wines. So he leans on an International selection to bring you better value in this price range.
Could Be Better: For more info on the Cellar Series, we suggest reading our full reviews for The Classic Series, The Vintners Series, and The Limited Series.
Overview: Among other "journey around the wine world" clubs Wine Awesomness stands out for exceptional educational materials. This is a great wine club for you if you're not sure yet if you're a "wine club" person or if you're looking to give a gift to a young wine-lover who's just starting to discover the world of wine.
What We Love: The level of sophistication in both design and writing of their monthly magazine and how the wine isn't expensive but is a very good value.
Could Be Better: So many people love to give wine subscriptions as gifts, and we think a gift packaging option and customizable gift notifications would add to the subscription gift option.
Overview: This 12-bottle case of wine club really jumpstarted this type of affordable wine subscription in the US and features value-focused white and red wines from around the world. Their $12 international wine selections typically offer better value in white wine than red. Take advantage of their introductory offer of just $69.99 for a case, but be warned, you are signing up for recurring shipments at $149.99.
What We Love: We've received many shipments of wine from the WSJwine Wine Club over the years, but we continue to hold the club in relatively low esteem. It's perfect for a wine lover who wants an inexpensive selection of International wine delivered to their door every quarter. It's not a good fit for anyone who likes wine that sells above $15 at the grocery store.
Could Be Better: Because of the success of the WSJwine club, many other wine clubs are competing with 12-bottle case clubs priced around $170 per quarter (including shipping costs). Some of them are offering much better quality wine for that price so we know they could, too.
Looking for a wine club subscription? We taste wine from nearly every wine club we review and rate the clubs objectively. Satisfaction guarantees, wine quality, convenience, discounts, and several other factors help us determine the best wine of the month clubs.
The best red wine can be pricey so pick a trusted wine club with a satisfaction guarantee. Quality & service is how you get on our list of best red wine clubs.
Wine clubs are the white wine lover's best friend. Excellent & affordable sums it up. There's so much more than Chardonnay and Sauvignon Blanc, so join one!
Value & affordability are not the same. Our best value clubs offer satisfaction guarantees, high QPR, & a range of prices. See why wine clubs are a great value.
Find budget nirvana by combining two smart wine shopping tactics: Buy by the case, get a subscription. These are the best quarterly case clubs on the market.
Looking for a cut above the regular wine selection in your next monthly club? Try one of these Premium wine clubs. The wines typically cost a little more, but you’ll find you have access to a more unique selection, and wines that are much harder to find at your local store or in another wine club.